15 February 2006

As congress looks into the handling, or mishandling, of disaster relief before, during, and after Katrina, the hurricane, by the Department of Homeland Security and its sub-agency, the Federal Emergency Management Agency, I’ve some thoughts on the subject myself.

Before I share those thoughts though, let me just say that first and foremost, I very strongly believe it to be an individual responsibility to protect oneself and one’s family in the face of any disaster. To put it simply, personal responsibility comes first, and last, in my humble opinion. Don’t take me wrong, it is the government’s inherent responsibility to protect and defend this nation from all enemies, foreign and domestic, but in the face of mother nature’s wrath, if the government is going to offer assistance, I expect nothing but the best from my tax dollars.

Having said that, I humbly suggest that the Department of Homeland Security, and the Federal Emergency Management Agency, ought not be just another set of bureaucratic agencies run by political appointees. Rather, and recognizing my bias towards the military, I feel strongly that the DHS and FEMA should be organized and ran much like our armed services. Why not hire retired military who have spent 20 to 30 years planning for and executing contingency operations? Both General Honore of the USA and Admiral Allen of the USCG performed famously in the aftermath of hurricanes Katrina and Rita. And they did so not because they had planned to be put in charge of that mission, but because they had spent a lifetime of leading a myriad of missions through severe adversities.

Not that anyone is asking, but my reccommendation is to re-look how we’ve organized and staffed the DHS and FEMA. I’m just saying. What say you? Sgt Hook out.


Posted by Hook @ 0326 zulu | | Permalink
This post is filed under: Americana & Soap Box



13 Comments »
  1. Absolutely agree with you, there was marked difference once the General arrived on the scene. I don’t really think many civilians are/can be prepared for reaction to events such as this. Even if they are trained there is a difference between actual experience vice ” response drilling” once a disaster (natural or man-made) occurs.

    Comment by Gypsy — 15 February 2006 @ 0344


  2. Oh yeah, personal accountability and being prepared “for the worst” is also up to individuals.

    Comment by Gypsy — 15 February 2006 @ 0345


  3. As an individual who prepared extensively for when Hurricane Katrina hit Mississippi, it was such a massive disaster, outside help was sorely needed.

    Infrastucture such as roads, police stations, fire stations, emergency command centers, utilities, and communication were destroyed by the massive storm surge and high winds. The Marines stationed at the Gulfport NCBC were the first ones out to rescue people. The Coast Guard was a close second.

    On the Mississippi Gulf Coast the men and women stationed at both the air force base and the Seabee base were very instrumental in helping our mayors, policemen, & firemen set-up communications, restore utilites, clear roads, etc. We sort of expect them to help out after disasters and they do. They are still helping. I saw some from the Seabee base yesterday repairing the boardwalk along Hwy 90 in Biloxi.

    The local leaders and the commanders of both the air force and Seabee base work closely together and have done an outstanding job.

    Comment by seawitch — 15 February 2006 @ 0421


  4. Makes damned good sense to me. The Coasties shined, big time and didn’t get nearly enought credit. Sadly, I suppose those fine men and women are accustomed to that, but it doesn’t stop them from doing a critical job every day.

    Comment by Jim - PRS — 15 February 2006 @ 0858


  5. I realize that finger pointing is not productive, but… That N.O. Mayor ought to be charged with murder. NOT to strong language there, as he did not follow his own city’s published plan, which called for the city to move folks out on the busses. The busses parked until they were flooded, etc. You’ve all seen the pictures and stories. Can you imagine the hue and cry if Nagin had been white? Why is he not in jail, or at least out of office? How many deaths was he directly responsible for?

    FEMA got into the act in 3 or 4 days; typical of the guberment, with all the crappy bureocracy it represents. Why is anyone surprised? If the entire government were run the way the military runs its shop, we would have fewer problems. Sgt.Hook, I’d vote for your plan in a heartbeat.

    Comment by JebTexas — 15 February 2006 @ 0940


  6. Very good points and ones I agree with. I live in earthquake country and have an earthquake kit to see me through for a week should disaster strike. After New Orleans, I added a .357 fully loaded and two speed loaders. I am prepared to take care of my own.

    Frankly, one of the reasons our country’s fabric is being torn asunder is that our citizens are not prepared to stand on their own and take responsibility for their lives. I guess I’m old-fashioned and have the blood of our founders coursing through me because I feel it is my responsibility to take care of myself and those I love and do what I can for my country.

    Comment by Cheryl — 15 February 2006 @ 1421


  7. As much as I hate to admit it, I live in Southeast Louisiana. I couldn’t agree with you more. If it weren’t for the military, we would still have people perched on rooptops and camped out at the Superdome and Convention Center.

    Comment by Sue — 15 February 2006 @ 1643


  8. I couldn’t agree with you more. The country had a chance to have DHS run by a proven leader, Bernard Kerik, who was not military as far as I know but was a proven leader, but the idiots in the government and media pressured him into stepping down because he had apparently accidently hired one of the illegal aliens that the President and Congress insist on allowing into our land.

    Comment by Anthony — 15 February 2006 @ 1715


  9. Excellent post… yes, I do agree with you. ;)

    Comment by Shayna — 15 February 2006 @ 1828


  10. Excellent post and I agree completely! We were totally lost after Katrina hit and there was so much destruction and there was no power, water, food or gasoline. Surely could have been better organized.

    Comment by Kim — 15 February 2006 @ 2018


  11. Gotta disagree Sgt. Vets are mostly running the companies delivering supplies and security in Iraq and from what I saw on Frontline (Scott Helvenston was working for one of them) they are botching the job.

    Send in the military, period.

    Comment by Sgt Lori Fields — 15 February 2006 @ 2314


  12. Sgt Lori,
    DHS and FEMA have unique missions that while often involve using the military, I don’t think they should get into the warfighting business which is the military’s primary role. As for the problems with contractors in Iraq, they’re just that, contractors and a little harder for governmental control other than cancelling the contract. A governmental department/agency answers to a higher power, the people.

    Comment by Hook — 15 February 2006 @ 2357


  13. Personally, for me….I don’t understand why we have FEMA, we have the National Guard. But who am I to say?

    Comment by Sgt Lori Fields — 17 February 2006 @ 1957


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment




Pin Ups for Vets



Proud Sponsors




Orderly Room


Baghdad

About Hook
Contact Hook



Obligatory Disclaimer


This site is a collection of my writings, thoughts, and ramblings and in no way reflects the official positions of the United States Army or the Department of Defense. OPSEC trumps everything.


Current Ops



Hook Publishing


Jackie O'Shea
Jaffy Chronicles
No Tears in Heaven


Hook Productions


I Dreamed It
The Soldier's Silent Night
Here Comes The Sun
You Raise Me Up
One of Those Great Stories
American Soldier
Would You Know My Name


Rules Of Engagement


Copyright © 2003 - 2008. All original content is copyrighted by Sgt Hook. Limited use of said material is authorized given proper attribution provided. Plagiarism is considered a serious breach around these parts and violators will face a firing squad. Any comments left or emails sent become the property of Sgt Hook and are subject to publishing herein. Writing "Confidential" in the subject line of your email will preclude publication of said email.


Proud Sponsors


Visit these Advertisers

♦ Veterans - Use your VA Benefits to Refinance your home loan with VA Loan Refinancing from VLC.


♦ Allured by a cheap car insurance and other cheap deals. Many tend to overspend on their credit card. This leads them to loans and eventually a debt. If you are planning to work at home, you will have to be careful about all this and more.


Sound Off


Cup and Flower


Fall In


ARMY
COAST GUARD
MARINE CORPS
NAVY
AIR FORCE


NOTAM


In view of a recent tendency to identify characters in fiction with real people, it seems proper to state that there are no real people in this volume: both the characters and their names are ficticious. The names or designations of any military units are ficticious. There are no living people nor existing military units presented in this book. -Ernest Hemingway


Band of Brothers



Prev | List | Random | Next
Join
Powered by RingSurf!

Recent Dispatches


Twelfth Night Month, Or What You Will
Checking In
Update
Soldiers’ Angel
Humble Apologies
The Underwater Cable Guy
Tales from the Sandbox
Second only to Combat
Operation Browning
Remember Fallujah?
It Is Safe Here
Cleaning House and Digging In
Mourning Heroes
Terror at Wali Dar
Caption This


Rank and File



My Ecosystem Details



View My Milblogging.com Profile


Ongoing Ops





Fiddler's Green


Halfway down the road to hell,
In a shady meadow green,
Are the souls of all dead troopers camped
Near a good old-time canteen.
And this eternal resting place
Is known as Fiddler's Green.
-Author Unknown


The Blog of War


"Grab it before the Pentagon orders it burned..." - Vanity Fair

"...nonpartisan patriotism is the common thread tying together these reflections, love letters and stories of combat. They make for riveting reading." - The Washington Post

Winner of the 2006 Gold Medal for Anthologies - Military Writer's Society of America

"This collection is an excellent introduction to an emerging form of war reporting." - Booklist


Annals

September 2008
July 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
February 2004
July 2003
June 2003
May 2003
April 2003
March 2003


Giving Credit

Powered by:
WordPress v. 2.3
Blog Design:
E.Webscapes
Hosted by:
Blogs About Hosting

Other

login
register


Meta

RSS
Comments RSS
WP


0.279 || Powered by WordPress